Progressive Minds

Blogging live, from somewhere in the reality-based community. Speaking truth to power. You've entered the real "no spin zone." Republicans beware!

2006/4/8

"A Concerted Action"

@ 11:41 PM (97 months, 21 days ago)

Absolutely required reading today, courtesy of The Washington Post.

According to the Post, CIA Leak Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald has described a "concerted action" among "multiple people in the White House" to seek revenge against Ambassador Joseph Wilson, who critized BushCo's so-called case for war with Iraq.

Moreover, Dick Cheney directed Scooter Libby to disclose to reporters the contents of a National Intelligence Estimate and a March 2002 summation of Wilson's trip to Niger.

But here's the real kicker---the "evidence" that Cheney and Libby chose to disclose to reporters, had already been DISPROVED (in other words, debunked) months before!

In their rush to trash Joseph Wilson for simply telling the truth about what he did not find in Africa- Cheney and Libby passed on bogus, disproved information.

Read on....

A 'Concerted Effort' to Discredit Bush Critic

Prosecutor Describes Cheney, Libby as Key Voices Pitching Iraq-Niger Story

Comment(s) »

  1. Gee whiz, so if they only passed on bogus information, then the only thing they did wrong was to uncover a CIA operative. So the president ONLY disclosed Plame. It's just one felony, right?

    Comment by John Sinton— 2006/04/09 @ 12:51 AM — (Reply)

  2. This is so bittersweet (like Sarah Silverman's dotcor story). On the one hand, it's great that the media has finally gotten around to reporting this, just as it's great that they finally started to do some (limited) reporting on the Downing Street memo. But it's been so long all this stuff was so known. I knew the aluminum tube and Wilson stuff before the Iraq war, before the SOTU then, and I'm not super plugged in I have no secret contacts. I can just read is all. And the info that was widely and readily available on leftish blogs then wasn't, mostly, original reporting, just reporting from sources readily available to anyone. BBC, CBC, and some US news sources nothing weird, conspiracy theory-ish, just solid, stolid, news organizations. Why can't news people making anywhere from 2X to 50X what I've ever made as a salary why can't people who are presumably, supposedly, competent enough to earn those salaries do as well as a guy like me a just a guy ?Can we get some remedial reading/comprehension courses for our news media? We need it they need it rather more than our kids do.

    Comment by Mauro— 2013/06/12 @ 03:13 PM — (Reply)

  3. That\'s not just the best answer. It\'s the bestest answer!

    Comment by cheap car insurance plans for new jersey— 2013/11/03 @ 07:47 AM — (Reply)

  4. Superior thinking demonstrated above. Thanks!

    Comment by http://www.childsoldierrelief.org/— 2013/12/12 @ 09:51 AM — (Reply)

  5. Dear Libby,I have just come across your Self care forum and found it of great interest. I am a Self care therapist in St Andrews Healthcare in Northampton. My work is very much about the promotion of Wellbeing and promoting positive and practical ways to maintain a healthy lifestyle within our secure environment. I am not sure if you know much about our Charity but there is a great deal of work going on throughout the organisation, particularly within our Health Promotion group and the Wellbeing group which sits within our HR directorate. Our aim is to provide both Service users and staff with the skills and tools to maintain Health and Wellbeing, within an environment which can at times be challenging and stressful.There is lots more I could tell you, but thought I would just introduce myself and briefly profile the Self care therapy work that is delivered within St Andrews Healthcare.I would very much appreciate it if you could add me to your mailing list, as I am sure some of your resources may be of benefit in terms of ideas and new strategies .If this is possible could you also add Arleen Rowell (Head of dietetics) to this mailing list. Her Email is .Look forward to hearing from you.Kind regardsLiz

    Comment by quote for car insurance— 2013/06/19 @ 01:39 AM — (Reply)

  6. We need more insights like this in this thread.

    Comment by online viagra prices— 2013/08/27 @ 07:06 AM — (Reply)

  7. There’s actually something “altogether fitting and proper” about the current political situation in the United States of America, most people are too damn lazy to do anything except write an email to their congress person or senators except on those very, very rare days when all hell freezes over. I vaguely recall that the last time that happened was 9-11-01. We have two congressional parties, a president, and a federal court system, bound and determined to destroy everything that has been built. Lord I pray the Armed Forces don’t remember that they swore to protect this country from all enemies “foreign and domestic”. If they ever do, there might not be a stone left standing inside the beltway. (SarcOff)Ever wonder where wild-eyed whackos with Kentucky Long Rifles come from? How about crazy rebels? Always wondered what it was that made those fools leave home and stand sholder to sholder in front of a battery of canon. Must be something in the water. Right? But there does seem to be a connection between lazy, foolish, stupid, worthless politicians and popular unrest, riots, uprisings, civil wars, and revolutions of one form or another.

    Comment by cheap auto insurance— 2013/06/23 @ 02:25 AM — (Reply)

  8. http://edtreatmentoffers.net/|Best prices on Cialis or Viagra aql http://www.leadingautoinsurers.net/auto-insurance-quotes-south-dakota.html|Sioux Falls auto insurance quotes 167 http://www.aboutcarinsurancerates.com/|car insurance quotes 291906 http://www.cheapinsurersinyourstate.com/|insurance car articles uygmhq http://www.insurancequoteslist.net/|auto insurance mfxt http://www.mycarinsuranceprovider.com/|auto insurance cheap nrdf http://insuredcar.net/|liability insurance worker >:)

    Comment by Midge— 2013/07/26 @ 03:12 AM — (Reply)

  9. I never thought I would find such an everyday topic so enthralling!

    Comment by cheap car insurance— 2013/11/10 @ 11:20 AM — (Reply)

  10. That\'s a genuinely impressive answer.

    Comment by liability insurance for— 2014/01/14 @ 11:25 AM — (Reply)

  11. http://bestedpillsonline.net/|viagra online >:-( http://cheappricesforedmedicine.com/|viagra for sale rtimdj http://www.bestskincareproduct.net/|accutane attorneys abbeville japvsx http://www.helpforedonline.com/|cialis online prescription 316

    Comment by Etty— 2013/08/04 @ 01:42 PM — (Reply)

  12. Nothing I could say would give you undue credit for this story.

    Comment by buy cialis— 2013/10/10 @ 04:15 AM — (Reply)

  13. http://www.carinsurquote.net/|liability insurance horse jwviss http://bestedpillsonline.net/|viagra online tipz http://www.medsmarkt.com/|On line viagra 961156 http://www.rightplacetobuymeds.com/|cialis online sales =DDD http://www.onlineedrugs.com/|Viagra Without Prescription Overnight ixdyre

    Comment by Gracelyn— 2013/08/17 @ 11:23 AM — (Reply)

  14. Thanks alot - your answer solved all my problems after several days struggling

    Comment by collector car insurance american— 2013/10/22 @ 09:27 PM — (Reply)

  15. That\'s the best answer of all time! JMHO

    Comment by car insurance quotes— 2014/01/08 @ 11:17 PM — (Reply)

  16. I searched a bunch of sites and this was the best.

    Comment by student health insurance— 2013/10/23 @ 07:31 PM — (Reply)

  17. doyxmn http://oswkfi.com/

    Comment by hello— 2014/01/12 @ 08:49 PM — (Reply)

  18. I happen to believe it's more than one felony.

    And I believe that the facts are already out there for everyone to see, regarding how this Administration lied to take us to war.

    I think we just need to go ahead and skip the impeachment hearings in the House. Skip the trial and the guilty/not guilty vote in the Senate, and go straight to removal from office.

    Comment by SMillard— 2006/04/09 @ 11:46 PM — (Reply)

  19. http://www.comparequotesonline.net/|compare car insurance 5421 http://www.mycarinsuranceprovider.com/cheap-car-insurance-virginia-beach.html|car insurance qoutes Virginia Beach >:-PPP http://choosecarinsurance.com/|cheap car insurance 16918 http://www.getacheapcoverage.com/|auto insurance quotes online 672477 http://www.mycarinsuranceprovider.com/cheap-car-insurance-philadelphia.html|Automoble Quotes Insurance Philadelphia jzk

    Comment by Kaylea— 2013/07/27 @ 01:38 PM — (Reply)

  20. Unparalleled accuracy, unequivocal clarity, and undeniable importance!

    Comment by xheap car insurance— 2013/11/16 @ 09:42 AM — (Reply)

  21. Too many compliments too little space, thanks!

    Comment by cialis billigt— 2013/12/10 @ 12:53 PM — (Reply)

  22. This article achieved exactly what I wanted it to achieve.

    Comment by cheap auto insurance— 2013/12/21 @ 08:42 AM — (Reply)

  23. Your post has moved the debate forward. Thanks for sharing!

    Comment by wv car insurance— 2013/12/30 @ 05:49 AM — (Reply)

  24. This is a most useful contribution to the debate

    Comment by car insurance quotes— 2013/09/13 @ 04:23 AM — (Reply)

  25. Calling all cars, calling all cars, we\'re ready to make a deal.

    Comment by viagra order online— 2013/09/28 @ 07:16 AM — (Reply)

  26. Phenomenal breakdown of the topic, you should write for me too!

    Comment by best car insurance online— 2013/11/09 @ 10:10 AM — (Reply)

  27. Thanks alot - your answer solved all my problems after several days struggling

    Comment by how to order viagra— 2013/12/14 @ 04:16 PM — (Reply)

  28. Thanks for your thoughts. It\'s helped me a lot.

    Comment by cheap auto insurance georgia— 2013/11/15 @ 08:06 AM — (Reply)

  29. It\'s a pleasure to find someone who can identify the issues so clearly

    Comment by cheap auto insurance— 2013/12/16 @ 04:18 PM — (Reply)

  30. April 10, 2006, 7:26 a.m.
    Sixteen Words, Again
    The myth of a great sin lives on.

    In Sunday’s Washington Post Dafna Linzer and Barton Gellman provide their gullible readers with a reprise of one of the great myths of the runup to the Iraq war: that President Bush used blatantly false information to justify the war.

    The story revolves around various claims by several intelligence services that Saddam’s agents were trying to buy uranium in Africa. At least three European services — the French, the Italian, and the British — told Washington about the reported Iraqi efforts. Some of the reports were carefully described as "unconfirmed." Others were based on documents that were given to the American embassy in Rome by Italian journalists, some of which subsequently turned out to be forgeries. Still other reports were highly regarded by the Europeans, especially the British, which led President Bush to say, in his State of the Union speech (January 28, 2003): "The British Government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa."

    The consensus at CIA was highly critical of these reports (most CIA officials were against the war and didn’t want to be blamed for it), but the White House, understandably very suspicious of the quality of CIA’s information and analysis, had pushed hard to get more information. Ambassador Joe Wilson had been sent by CIA to Niger in 2002 to snoop around, at least in part because he came highly recommended by his wife, Valerie Plame, herself a CIA officer, and opposed to the war.

    After Bush’s State of the Union, Wilson claimed publicly that his trip had convinced him that the intelligence reports were groundless. However, he had reported privately — oddly enough in a verbal, not written, report to CIA — that a former high Nigerien official had said that the Iraqis had wanted high-level discussions about "increasing trade," which either meant uranium or goats.

    Nonetheless, after the war began, Wilson’s public remarks earned him celebrity status in New York and Washington, and the White House decided to try to discredit him. Accordingly, Scooter Libby was authorized to talk to select journalists (which the Washington Post editorially described as a "good leak") about some of the information that suggested Saddam was trying to get uranium in Africa. Libby’s actions just showed up in a filing by Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, and prompted the Linzer-Gellman story.

    Linzer and Gellman say, referring to the phony documents, that "the evidence Cheney and Libby selected to share with reporters had been disproved months before." And they add, in a triumphant tone reserved for the announcement of a knockout punch, that "the Bush administration and British Prime Minister Tony Blair maintained they had additional, secret evidence they could not disclose. In June, a British parliamentary inquiry concluded otherwise, delivering a scathing critique of Blair's role in promoting the story."

    But Linzer and Gellman are wrong, indeed so clearly wrong that it takes one’s breath away. The British government did indeed have information about Iraqi efforts to purchase uranium in Africa, and it wasn’t connected to the forgeries. And the definitive British parliamentary inquiry — the Butler Commission Report of July, 2004 — not only did not deliver "a scathing critique," but totally endorsed the position of British intelligence.

    The key paragraph in the Butler Report is this:

    We conclude that...the statements on Iraqi attempts to buy uranium from Africa in the Government’s dossier, and by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, were well-founded. By extension we conclude also that the statement in President Bush’s State of the Union Address of 28 January 2003 that: "The British Government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa" was well-founded. (Page 123, Paragraph 499)

    The British Intelligence Service, MI6, still stands by that story, as does the French service, the DGSE. And the two agencies did not base their assessments on the phony documents (indeed, the DGSE knew all about those documents, which were peddled and probably drafted by one or two Italian agents of theirs). According to London Sunday Times reporter Mick Smith — an outspoken critic of the American/British use of intelligence to justify the war, and an outspoken critic of Bush — the Franco/British analysis is based in part on a letter from Iraq’s Ambassador to the Vatican, that specifically discussed uranium from Niger. Smith also adds the delicious tidbit that the pile of forgeries actually contained an accurate document about the visit of Saddam’s man in the Vatican to Niger in 1999.

    So Linzer and Gellman are entirely wrong. Bush’s statement was true, and an extensive British parliamentary inquiry concluded that there was good reason for him, and Blair, to say so. Nonetheless, it is now part of the conventional wisdom to say that "the sixteen words" were a lie. How can that be? It’s not as if Bush’s critics need that detail in order to tear apart the bad intelligence work leading up to Operation Iraqi Freedom. There are enough errors to fill several volumes, as they have.

    Part of the answer — the other part being the malevolence and sloppiness of the press — is that the White House made a total hash of the whole thing, as is their wont. Indeed, if you go back and read the painful statements regarding "the sixteen words," you will find at least one in which Steven Hadley, then deputy national-security adviser, took full "responsibility" for the sin of including those words in the State of the Union. Incredibly for the fine lawyer he is, Hadley seems to have confessed to a crime he didn’t commit.

    Moreover, the entire Libby operation was misconceived. The White House was reacting to Wilson’s writings (and an earlier leak of his own to a New York Times columnist). Didn’t they know that Wilson’s actual report actually supported the president’s 16 words? If they did, they should have hung him with his own two-faced actions. If they did not, it was either because they didn’t press CIA for the whole story, or because CIA didn’t provide it, knowing it would have helped the White House to which they were legally obliged to tell the whole truth (maybe Fitzgerald, in his poor imitation of Savanarola, might like to look into that).

    Once again, when it comes to telling their own story, this administration has few peers in its ability to make a mess. Maybe they caught a bug from the Washington Post?

    Comment by — 2006/04/12 @ 01:15 AM — (Reply)

  31. Adorei esse episódio.Foi um dos meus favoritos e acabou sendo mais assustador que o episódio de Halloween. Vocês perceberam que a boneca de Alison – aquela que ela guardava suas coisas – aparece aos 16m e 40s? Se não, olhem. Pra mim tá muito claro que Alison está viva. É surreal que Emily, Spencer e Hannah tenham-na visto de maneiras tão singulares, e no entanto, tão parecidas. Lembro que vocês fizeram um ponto up! sobre isso. e eu acho que vocês acertaram. E outra. Vocês perceberam que o boneco com o rosto de -A por trás (36:42) tem exatamente o molde da máscara que as várias pessoas usaram no episódio de Halloween?E Jenna está tentando se livrar da culpa dela. Entregar Garret foi a coisa mais esperta que ela já fez, e isso recairá nas garotas. Porque Melissa acha que Spencer entregou Garret e ela vai tentar se vingar disso. E mais outra, -A é uma pessoa branca. Descartem Maia, Mona… E coloquem Lucas de novo como seus supeitos. E o próprio Jason (mesmo eu não querendo isso). E talvez o próprio Noam. Adorei a participação desse Seth. Tive muito medo dele. kkkk Gostei da crítica Bruna. Estou muito ansiosa pro episódio 25.

    Comment by on line car insurance— 2013/06/20 @ 01:52 AM — (Reply)

  32. This is the ideal answer. Everyone should read this

    Comment by midwest health insurance— 2013/09/22 @ 09:20 PM — (Reply)

  33. Thanks alot - your answer solved all my problems after several days struggling

    Comment by auto insurance quotes— 2013/12/22 @ 11:06 AM — (Reply)

  34. It\'s great to find someone so on the ball

    Comment by get cheap car insurance— 2013/12/24 @ 11:23 AM — (Reply)

  35. Many many quality points there.

    Comment by cheap viagra— 2014/01/01 @ 09:22 AM — (Reply)

  36. Free knowledge like this doesn\'t just help, it promote democracy. Thank you.

    Comment by quotes on auto ins— 2013/12/27 @ 06:21 AM — (Reply)

  37. There’s actually something “altogether fitting and proper” about the current political situation in the United States of America, most people are too damn lazy to do anything except write an email to their congress person or senators except on those very, very rare days when all hell freezes over. I vaguely recall that the last time that happened was 9-11-01. We have two congressional parties, a president, and a federal court system, bound and determined to destroy everything that has been built. Lord I pray the Armed Forces don’t remember that they swore to protect this country from all enemies “foreign and domestic”. If they ever do, there might not be a stone left standing inside the beltway. (SarcOff)Ever wonder where wild-eyed whackos with Kentucky Long Rifles come from? How about crazy rebels? Always wondered what it was that made those fools leave home and stand sholder to sholder in front of a battery of canon. Must be something in the water. Right? But there does seem to be a connection between lazy, foolish, stupid, worthless politicians and popular unrest, riots, uprisings, civil wars, and revolutions of one form or another.

    Comment by low cost car insurers in nj— 2013/06/23 @ 02:25 AM — (Reply)

  38. You are so awesome for helping me solve this mystery.

    Comment by click here— 2013/10/17 @ 01:38 PM — (Reply)

  39. An intelligent answer - no BS - which makes a pleasant change

    Comment by car insurance— 2013/11/19 @ 01:49 PM — (Reply)

  40. This has made my day. I wish all postings were this good.

    Comment by auto insurance quotes— 2013/11/27 @ 06:16 PM — (Reply)

  41. http://www.onlinecheapautoinsur.com/|by car insurance group nae http://wemeatagain.com/|how can i buy viagra without prescription :)) http://www.shoppingforedtabs.com/|discount pharmacy purchase levitra 8( http://www.insurcompanieslist.com|nj auto insurance 650738 http://www.topcarprotection.com/charlotte-car-insurance-quotes.html|NC car insurance quotes 020

    Comment by Jazlynn— 2013/08/18 @ 06:57 AM — (Reply)

  42. Wow! Talk about a posting knocking my socks off!

    Comment by public liability insurance cost of— 2013/09/14 @ 10:02 PM — (Reply)

  43. No complaints on this end, simply a good piece.

    Comment by http://www.carinsurerslist.net— 2013/12/04 @ 10:57 AM — (Reply)

  44. Articles like this are an example of quick, helpful answers.

    Comment by prednisone online overnight— 2014/01/13 @ 10:49 AM — (Reply)

  45. I told my kids we'd play after I found what I needed. Damnit.

    Comment by cheap auto insurance— 2013/10/11 @ 06:41 PM — (Reply)

  46. It's great to read something that's both enjoyable and provides pragmatisdc solutions.

    Comment by buy prednisone online without prescription— 2013/10/16 @ 09:15 PM — (Reply)

  47. I\'m not quite sure how to say this; you made it extremely easy for me!

    Comment by Levitra cheap— 2013/12/01 @ 02:37 AM — (Reply)

  48. A wonderful job. Super helpful information.

    Comment by cheap auto insurance— 2013/12/03 @ 01:11 AM — (Reply)

  49. Heckuva good job. I sure appreciate it.

    Comment by car insurance quotes— 2013/11/25 @ 08:14 AM — (Reply)

  50. It\'s really great that people are sharing this information.

    Comment by insureyourcaronline.com— 2013/12/29 @ 06:46 PM — (Reply)

  51. Just what the doctor ordered, thankity you!

    Comment by liability insurance co— 2013/11/21 @ 06:21 PM — (Reply)

» Leave a comment


:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?:

Preview:

You say:

To prevent spam, please type in the exact word you see in this image: CAPTCHA
To refresh the image, click here. Otherwise, contact us.

  • Your E-mail address is never displayed. If you enter it, it will only be visible to the blog author
  • Since there already are over 25 comments to this post, your eventual comment will no longer trigger a notification e-mail to the persons that commented before you.
  • The line and paragraph breaks automatically